Why Collectors Consign with Us

Every consigned item is carefully reviewed. Research may include maker, period, catalog references, comparable examples, provenance (when known), and condition.

Before anything is offered for sale, we align with you on pricing, commission, condition notes and disclosure.

No item is ever listed without your explicit approval.

Pricing is set collaboratively and informed by market history, collector demand, and the nature of the object.

While we may recommend pricing based on experience, all pricing decisions are agreed upon together. If market conditions change over time, we may suggest adjustments for discussion.

Commission rates vary depending on the material and scope of the consignment. Terms are discussed and agreed upon in advance.

Because material is presented directly to a specialized audience of magic collectors, consignors often achieve stronger realized prices than they might through broader marketplaces.

While an item is consigned with The Magic Collector, it is offered for sale exclusively through us. This ensures clear pricing, consistent presentation, and a straightforward experience for all parties.

Consignments are not subject to fixed terms and may be withdrawn at any time with reasonable notice.

Shipping to The Magic Collector

Shipping items to us is your responsibility, including packing and shipping costs. We are happy to advise on packing best practices to ensure safe arrival.

Shipping to the Buyer

We cover the cost of shipping to the buyer. We handle packing and shipment, including carrier selection, insurance, and signature requirements when appropriate. Shipping fees over $10 (our flat rate fee) are deducted from your final payout.

Items are handled, stored, and presented with collector-level care. Descriptions are written to be historically respectful, accurate, and transparent. Unless otherwise agreed, items are not insured beyond standard business coverage while in our possession.

Once an item is sold and delivered, the sale is considered final unless otherwise required by law.

Payment to the consignor is issued within an agreed timeframe following cleared buyer funds. A clear breakdown of the sale price, commission, and net proceeds is always provided.

In the event of a return request, we will consult with you before proceeding.

No. Consignments are ongoing unless otherwise specified. You may request the return of unsold items at any time with reasonable notice.

Return shipping costs are the responsibility of the consignor unless otherwise agreed.

eBay is a broad marketplace designed for speed of sale, while major auction houses often focus on large, highly selective sales.

The Magic Collector sits between those models, offering focused placement for historically significant, collectible magic where context, accuracy, and audience matter.

Many items belong in open marketplaces. Others benefit from careful presentation, individual consideration, and a knowledgeable collector audience. We’re always happy to talk through the pros and cons for your material.